Small-space gardens, herbs and a kitchen apothecary

Menu

field notes

Seed Starting Mix: DIY vs Store-Bought for a Small Garden

For a few trays, buy a bag of seed starting mix. For lots of cells, mix equal parts coir or peat, vermiculite and fine perlite yourself. This guide compares the two, gives the recipe, a worked quantity example and a list of what to leave out.

This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you. Read our disclosure.

Safety first: Herbs can be powerful. If you are pregnant, nursing, take medication or have a health condition, check with your doctor or pharmacist first. Please read our herbal & garden safety notes before you start.

Key takeaways

  • UGA Extension lists equal parts peat or coir, vermiculite and perlite
  • Seed starting mix is fine, light, low in nutrients and sterile
  • Avoid garden soil and old potting soil
  • A 72-cell tray of 2 cubic inch cells needs about 2.5 quarts (our worked example)
  • Feed at half strength after the first true leaves
In this post9 sections
  1. Verdict: buy a bag for a small garden, mix your own for 100+ cells
  2. Seed starting mix vs potting soil
  3. Make your own: the equal-parts recipe
  4. How much mix do you need?
  5. Cost: when mixing your own starts to pay
  6. First two weeks: what goes wrong and the fix
  7. What not to put in the mix
  8. Store the leftovers and label the trays
  9. FAQ

Verdict: buy a bag for a small garden, mix your own for 100+ cells

For a few trays on a windowsill, buy a bag of seed starting mix. For a lot of cells, or if you like to control what goes in, mix your own from equal parts peat or coir, vermiculite and perlite. Both work. What does not work well is ordinary potting soil or garden soil, which are too heavy and rich for tiny seedlings.

The equal-parts recipe comes from University of Georgia Extension. Other extension sources list slightly different ratios, such as 2:1:1, so there is no single official recipe; the goal is a mix that is fine, light, low in nutrients and clean.

Equal parts coir, vermiculite and perlite.

Seed starting mix vs potting soil

Seed starting mix compared with potting soil and garden soil
Seed starting mixPotting soilGarden soil
TextureFine and lightCoarser, heavierDense, clumps
NutrientsLow, by designOften highVariable
Disease and weedsSterileMay carry someOften present
Drainage in cellsEven and airyCan stay wetPoor
Best useGerminating seedsPotting up seedlingsIn the ground only

Extension sources say seed starting mix is soilless, fine, light and sterile, while potting soil is too dense and rich for seeds and may carry weeds and disease. Large seeds such as beans or squash tolerate regular potting mix according to University of Maryland Extension, but small seeds do not.

Make your own: the equal-parts recipe

  1. Step 1: Soak the coir

    If you use a coir brick, soak it in a bucket of warm water until it expands and fluffs apart. UGA Extension calls coir the more sustainable choice compared with peat.

  2. Step 2: Measure equal parts

    Measure one part coir or peat, one part vermiculite and one part fine perlite, using the same scoop. Use fine perlite, not the big chunks.

  3. Step 3: Blend and pre-moisten

    Mix in a bucket, then add a little water until the mix feels like a wrung-out sponge. Dry mix repels water and seeds dry out.

  4. Step 4: Do the squeeze test

    Squeeze a handful. It should hold together but not drip. If water runs out, add dry mix. If it crumbles apart, add water.

  5. Step 5: Fill the cells

    Fill cells loosely, tap the tray once, and top off. Do not press down hard.

  6. Step 6: Label and sow

    Label every tray. Our seed starting supplies guide covers lights, trays and heat mats.

How much mix do you need?

Here is a worked example, not a rule. A 72-cell tray with 2 cubic inch cells holds about 144 cubic inches of mix. One quart is 57.75 cubic inches, so that is about 2.5 quarts per tray. Buy or mix a little extra for topping off. Our printable seed starting calendar shows when to start each crop so you can plan how many trays you will fill.

Cost: when mixing your own starts to pay

The fair way to compare is price per quart, because bags and bricks come in different sizes. Divide the price on the shelf by the quarts printed on the label. Do it once for a bag of seed starting mix and once for each of your three ingredients, then add up one third of each ingredient's per-quart price to get your DIY per-quart cost.

Worked example only: plug in the prices and quart sizes from your own store
Bagged mixDIY 1:1:1
What you buyOne bagCoir brick, vermiculite, perlite
Up-front spendLower: one bagHigher: three products at once
Price per quartBag price divided by quartsAbout a third of each ingredient's per-quart price, added up
LeftoversLittle or nonePlenty, stored dry for next season
Best for1 to 2 trays a season3 or more trays, or every spring

Here is the pattern most small gardens hit. With one or two 72-cell trays you need about 5 quarts, using the 2.5 quarts per tray worked out above. A single bag covers that, and buying three ingredients to make 5 quarts leaves most of them on a shelf. Once you fill three or more trays, or you start seeds every spring, the leftover ingredients get used and the per-quart price usually drops below the bag. These are our own sums, not a price survey, so check the labels where you shop.

First two weeks: what goes wrong and the fix

Common problems

Most of these trace back to water and air, not to whether the mix came from a bag or a bucket. A light, clean mix gives you more room for error, which is why both options above beat garden soil.

What not to put in the mix

Leave these out

UGA Extension says the mix should be low in fertility, with feeding starting after the first true leaves at half strength. Compost may add microbes but also disease risk, so many gardeners add it later when they pot up.

Store the leftovers and label the trays

Keep dry leftover mix in a lidded bucket with the ratio on the lid. Moisten only what you will use that day. The Seed Starting Planner and Zone Calendars ($7) logs what you sowed and when, and the Small-Space Garden Binder ($25) keeps it all in one place.

Ingredients and tools for seed starting mix

Frequently asked questions

Can I use potting soil to start seeds?

You can for large seeds, but it is usually too heavy and rich for small seeds. University of Maryland Extension notes large seeds tolerate regular potting mix.

What is the best ratio for DIY seed starting mix?

University of Georgia Extension lists equal parts peat or coir, vermiculite and perlite. Other sources use 2:1:1. There is no single official ratio.

Is coir or peat better for seed starting mix?

UGA Extension calls coir the more sustainable choice. Both hold water and work in the mix.

Do I need to add fertilizer?

Not at first. Feed at half strength after the first true leaves appear.

Can I reuse seed starting mix?

We do not recommend reusing old potting soil for seed starting. Use fresh mix for each tray to limit disease.

Pinterest collage of coir, vermiculite and perlite in bowls with the text 5 easy ways to make seed starting mix.

Save it for later

Pin this to your Seasonal Garden Tasks board so it's there when you need it.

Save to Pinterest

About the author

Iris Calder, Seasonal & DIY Writer

Iris Calder is a pen name used by the independent publisher of Herb & Hollow for its seasonal garden tasks, garden DIY and balcony and container guides. Iris isn't a trained horticulturist, so posts are built from university extension services, USDA zone and frost-date data and seed-company growing information, with AI tools helping on research, drafts and images. Each post is checked against those sources before it goes live and updated when they change. Nothing here is medical advice.

Reviewed by Hazel Morrow, Founder & Editor. Read our editorial guidelines.

Every Herb & Hollow guide is checked against zone, extension and safety sources and reviewed by a human editor before publishing.

Love this? Save it for later. Save